Deferred compensation plans can be a smart way to manage taxes and build long-term wealth. They can also be surprisingly unforgiving. Over the years, we’ve noticed that many executives sign up based on what a colleague told them or what they assumed the plan did, and those assumptions don’t always hold up.
Our friends at Grey Ocean, PC discuss how misunderstandings about these plans often come to light at the worst possible moment, such as a job change, a sale of the company, or retirement. Speaking with a deferred compensation lawyer before you make elections or sign a new agreement can help you avoid unpleasant surprises down the road. Below are some of the most common myths we hear and what’s actually true.
“It Works Just Like My 401(k)”
This might be the most widespread misconception. A 401(k) is a qualified plan, which means your money sits in a trust that’s protected from the company’s creditors.
A nonqualified deferred compensation plan is different. In most cases, it’s simply the company’s promise to pay you later. If the business runs into serious financial trouble or files for bankruptcy, you may stand in line with other unsecured creditors. Some companies set aside assets in what’s called a rabbi trust, but even those funds can usually be reached by creditors. The financial health of your employer matters far more than most people realize.
“I Can Change My Payout Date if My Plans Change”
Not easily. Federal tax rules require you to lock in when and how you’ll be paid, usually before you earn the compensation. Want the money sooner because you’re buying a house? That generally isn’t allowed. Under the IRS’s final regulations, an early payment of deferred compensation is usually treated as an impermissible acceleration.
Pushing payments further out is possible in limited situations, but the rules are strict. Before you choose a lump sum or installments, think carefully about where you’ll be years from now.
“Compliance Is the Company’s Problem, Not Mine”
We understand why people believe this. The employer drafts the plan and runs it. But when a plan fails to follow Section 409A, the tax hit falls mostly on the employee.
According to the IRS final rules on deferred compensation, if a plan doesn’t meet the requirements, deferred amounts generally become taxable right away rather than when you actually receive them. On top of that, additional taxes and interest can apply. You could owe money on compensation you haven’t been paid yet.
“These Rules Only Apply to Retirement Plans”
Many people picture deferred compensation as a supplemental retirement benefit for senior executives. That’s part of it. But the rules reach much further than most expect, and they can apply to arrangements such as:
- Severance and separation pay provisions
- Certain bonus plans with delayed payment dates
- Some stock appreciation rights and phantom stock awards
- Payments tied to non-compete agreements
A single clause in an employment contract can create a deferred compensation arrangement without anyone calling it that.
“If I Leave, I’ll Get My Money Right Away”
Sometimes. Often not.
Your payout follows the schedule set in the plan and your elections, not your timeline. Executives at public companies may also face a mandatory waiting period after leaving. And some plans include forfeiture provisions, so unvested amounts can disappear if you resign early or go to work for a competitor. Read the vesting and forfeiture language before you give notice, not after.
Getting Clear Answers About Your Plan
These plans reward careful planning and penalize guesswork. The documents are dense, the deadlines are firm, and a decision made in a few minutes during open enrollment can follow you for years. If you have questions about your deferred compensation plan or are weighing an election or job change, we encourage you to connect with an attorney who can walk through your agreement with you and explain your options.